Skip to Content

Book Summary and Review: Signal Fires by Dani Shapiro

signal fires book summary and review

Editorial note: I received a copy of Signal Fires by Dani Shapiro in exchange for a review. All opinions are my own.

Book review and synopsis for Signal Fires by Dani Shapiro, a haunting tale of family secrets and the intricate web of human connections.

With its beautifully rendered prose and emotionally resonant characters, this book will invite you to ponder the complexities of human relationships and the power of forgiveness.

But is it worth reading? ❤️

Signal Fires by Dani Shapiro

Plot Summary | Book Review | Criticism | Read or Skip? | Book Club Questions

Plot Summary

In the serene suburb of Avalon, New York, a seemingly ordinary night in 1985 takes a tragic turn when three teenagers are involved in a fatal car accident.

Fifteen-year-old Theo Wilf, driving without a license, crashes the car with his sister Sarah and her friend Misty Zimmerman inside. The accident sets off a chain of events that alters the lives of the Wilf family and the Shenkmans, their neighbors across the street.

Signal Fires unfolds across multiple timelines, weaving the stories of these families together. The narrative bounces between pivotal moments in 1985, 1999, 2010, 2014, and 2020, exploring the consequences of that fateful night.

The Wilf family secrets, especially the one surrounding the accident, cast a shadow over their lives, affecting relationships, choices, and destinies.

At the heart of the story is the unlikely connection between Ben Wilf, a retired doctor, and Waldo Shenkman, a young boy fascinated by the stars.

Their bond, forged under an ancient oak tree and nurtured by Waldo’s passion for constellations, becomes a beacon of hope amid the darkness of their respective lives.

Book Review

Signal Fires is Dani Shapiro’s 11th book, and I have to say, it’s a novel that surprised me in the best way possible. Right from the start, with that heart-stopping crash in 1985, I was hooked. But what followed was a journey into the quieter corners of human existence, filled with deep philosophical musings and unexpected connections.

One thing that struck me is Shapiro’s exploration of family secrets, a theme she delved into with such raw honesty in her bestselling memoir “Inheritance.” In “Signal Fires,” the Wilf family harbors a secret so profound that it remains unspoken, shaping their lives in unimaginable ways. As the story unfolds, Shapiro skillfully takes us through different moments in time, revealing the intricacies of their lives with meticulous attention to detail.

Shapiro’s writing is nothing short of poetic, drawing readers into the depths of human emotions and relationships. The characters are richly developed, each struggling with their own demons and haunted by the events of that night in 1985.

What I found the most interesting about this novel was Shapiro’s ability to navigate the complexities of family dynamics with sensitivity and grace. The characters are flawed and relatable, making it easy to empathize with their struggles and triumphs. The narrative’s non-linear structure adds depth to the storytelling, allowing readers to piece together the puzzle of these intertwined lives.

Characters’ destinies were particularly moving, especially Theo, who becomes a renowned chef, and Sarah, a successful screenwriter. Shapiro paints their careers with such vivid authenticity that I felt like I was right there with them, experiencing their triumphs and challenges.

I was particularly moved by the scenes between 74-year-old Ben Wilf and young Waldo Shenkman. The introduction of the Star Walk app, allowing them to witness the vastness of the universe, added a layer of profound wonder to the story. The idea that all versions of a person coexist at every moment struck a chord with me, making me reflect on the complexity of human experience.

And the way Shapiro chose to end the story, not with a neat resolution, but by going back to where it all began in 1970, felt incredibly poignant. It reminded me that life is a tapestry of moments, both beautiful and heartbreaking. “Signal Fires” doesn’t shy away from the pain of loss but embraces it with a sense of grace, leaving me with a bittersweet feeling that lingers even after I’ve turned the last page.

Some criticism

While the fragmented narrative style enhances the depth of the story, it might be a bit disorienting for readers who prefer linear storytelling. Some might find the nonlinear timeline a tad confusing, requiring careful attention to the shifting perspectives and time periods.

Additionally, the occasional mystical elements introduced in the story might feel slightly out of place for readers seeking a strictly realistic narrative. These moments, while poetic, might require readers to suspend their disbelief.

Read it or skip it?

Without a doubt, Signal Fires is a literary gem that deserves a place on every bookshelf.

If you enjoy beautifully crafted stories about family, love, and the interconnectedness of lives, this novel is a must-read. Shapiro’s writing is both poignant and mesmerizing, making Signal Fires a deeply satisfying and emotionally resonant experience.

I find myself reflecting on the characters and their journeys long after turning the last page, and I can’t help but wonder about the hidden constellations within my own life.

P.S. For my book club questions for this book, click here!

Happy reading! ❤️