This post may contain affiliate links. Read more here.
Book club questions for The Beach at Summerly by Beatriz Williams explore the themes of love, sacrifice, and intrigue in a mid-century New England setting.
This ravishing summer read takes us back to June 1946 on Winthrop Island, where the aftermath of war blends with the allure of a glamorous newcomer, Olive Rainsford. As the daughter of Summerly’s caretaker, Emilia Winthrop finds herself drawn into a world of possibilities through her connection with Olive and the tangled romantic history she shares with the Peabody sons.
Reading this book, I felt completely immersed in a tale of adventure and romance, in a world the promise of a bright future with the intrigue of espionage and the shadows of dark secrets. Emilia’s journey takes unexpected twists, and as the story unfolds, we find ourselves transported to April 1954, where the echoes of her past actions and the weight of her choices come to a head. It’s a rollercoaster of emotions that will keep you eagerly turning the pages, eager to unravel the mysteries that lie ahead.
This post contains the book club questions for The Beach at Summerly for discussion with your book club. At the bottom of the post, I have also attached the book club questions in a downloadable PDF for your convenience. I hope you find it useful! Let me know your thoughts in the comment section below.
About the Story
The Beach at Summerly is a riveting summer read that will take you back to mid-century New England. The story follows Emilia Winthrop, whose life changes when glamorous Olive Rainsford arrives at Summerly estate, revealing a world of possibilities.
Amid tangled romantic history with the Peabody brothers, Emilia is thrust into Cold War intrigue when an FBI agent seeks her help to catch a Soviet spy on the island. Fast forward eight years, and Emilia’s choices come back to haunt her, leading to a thrilling climax that could shatter lives and test redemption.
This is tale of love, secrets, and sacrifice, and will keep you hooked until the last page!
About the Author
Beatriz Williams is a bestselling historical fiction author, renowned for her captivating novels such as “Her Last Flight,” “The Summer Wives,” and “The Golden Hour,” among others. Graduating from Stanford University and holding an MBA in finance from Columbia University, she initially worked as a communications and corporate strategy consultant.
Beatriz’s books can be enjoyed in any order as most are standalone stories, except for the “Schuyler sister” novels like “The Secret Life of Violet Grant” and others. Inspired by her love for history, she immerses readers in the lives of her characters and crafts stories set in various time periods.
Besides her own works, Beatriz recommends authors like Patrick O’Brian, Daphne du Maurier, and Kate Morton.
Additionally, she has collaborated with authors Karen White and Lauren Willig to write books like “The Forgotten Room” and “The Glass Ocean.” For signed copies of her books, fans can inquire with Bank Square Books of Mystic, Connecticut, where she visits regularly for book signings.
Book Club Questions for The Beach at Summerly
I have also attached a free printable PDF of the book club questions for The Beach at Summerly by Beatriz Williams at the bottom of this post!✨
- At her father’s funeral, a neighbor astutely observes Emilia’s desire to be accepted by the privileged class, prompting us to ponder the complexities of the social hierarchy on Winthrop Island. Reflect on how Emilia navigates the distinct communities of the summer people and the year-rounders. Does she successfully bridge the divide, and how do her actions impact the dynamics between these groups?
- Emilia’s father’s decision not to accept the Peabodys’ offer of sending her to college raises intriguing questions about family dynamics and social standing. Explore the potential implications of such a choice on both families and their relationships. As Olive offers to revive the college offer, investigate her motivations and how this gesture shapes Emilia’s future.
- Delve into the emotional turmoil that Emilia faces upon discovering her father’s affair with Aunt Benedita. Put yourself in her shoes and consider the possible courses of action she could have taken. How would you have dealt with a similar revelation?
- Aunt Olive Rainsford is portrayed as a glamorous and enigmatic figure who influences Emilia’s life significantly. Consider the impact of mentorship and role models in the novel. How do Olive’s actions and advice shape Emilia’s journey and development as a character?
- Emilia and Olive share a deep connection, and Olive even makes a cryptic statement that Emilia will be grateful for her actions one day. Explore the complexities of their relationship and the significance of Olive’s confession to murdering Emilia’s mother. How does this revelation shape Emilia’s understanding of her past and her sense of self?
- Analyze the persuasive tactics used by Sumner Fox to involve Emilia in uncovering Olive’s espionage activities. Examine the sacrifices Emilia makes in collaborating with the FBI. Reflect on whether she would have made the same choice if she had been aware of the consequences she was setting in motion.
- Investigate the intriguing parallels between Emilia and Olive, as they both remark on the similarities they see in each other. Uncover the shared traits and experiences that bond them, as well as the differences that set them apart. How do these connections influence their relationship and the narrative as a whole?
- Emilia’s father’s belief that people don’t change prompts us to contemplate the theme of personal growth throughout the story. Analyze whether the characters evolve as the narrative unfolds, and specifically explore the transformation of Emilia from 1946 to 1954. How has her experiences shaped her, and is she a different person in the later timeframe?
- The revelation of Emilia’s mother choosing her father based on a mistaken assumption about his social status raises questions about family secrets and their impact. Examine how this revelation affects Emilia’s perception of her family and her own identity. How does this newfound knowledge reshape her understanding of her past?
- Unravel the complexities of Olive’s confession to murdering Emilia’s mother and her assertion that one day, Emilia will be grateful for it. Probe into the influence of Marxist ideology on Olive’s beliefs about the end justifying the means. Discuss the implications of this belief and whether there is any truth to it.
- The novel alternates between the years 1946 and 1954, allowing readers to witness the characters’ growth and evolution over time. Compare and contrast Emilia’s character in these two timeframes. How do her experiences and choices in 1946 shape her actions and decisions in 1954?
- Olive’s Marxist-influenced belief that the end justifies the means adds depth to the character’s motivations and actions. Discuss the implications of this belief in the context of the espionage plot and its consequences. How does Olive’s ideology shape her decisions, and what are the moral implications of her actions?
- “The Beach at Summerly” incorporates historical elements and real-life figures from the Cold War era. How does the author blend historical events with fictional storytelling, and how does this enhance the overall reading experience? Discuss the significance of including figures like Allen Dulles and the impact of real-world events on the characters’ lives.
- The exchange of Olive for the American spy Sasha Digby, whose story is featured in Beatriz Williams’ previous novel, sparks curiosity about interconnections between the two books. For those who have read “OUR WOMAN IN MOSCOW,” explore the continuation of Sasha’s story in “THE BEACH AT SUMMERLY.” How does this intertwining of narratives enrich the reading experience?
- Speculate on the mystery of the package Emilia receives at the novel’s conclusion. Delve into the potential senders and the significance of the enclosed speech titled “On the Cult of Personality and Its Consequences.” How does this enigmatic ending leave room for interpretation and reflection on the characters’ fates?
- The book explores the idea of summer as a fleeting, idyllic time associated with innocence and nostalgia. Consider the symbolism of summer in the novel and its connection to the characters’ experiences and personal growth. How does the summer setting contribute to the overall atmosphere and themes of the story?
- The theme of identity and the search for self-discovery is prevalent in the novel, particularly in Emilia’s journey. Analyze how Emilia’s experiences and relationships with other characters contribute to her understanding of her identity. How does her sense of self evolve from the beginning of the story to its conclusion?
- Imagine the future destinies of the characters beyond the book’s conclusion. As the narrative concludes in the mid-20th century, contemplate the possible trajectories of their lives in the later years. Discuss the implications of historical events and personal choices on their journeys in the remainder of the 20th century.
Selected Reviews for The Beach at Summerly
“The Summer Wives is an exquisitely rendered novel that tackles two of my favorite topics: love and money. The glorious setting and drama are enriched by Williams’s signature vintage touch. It’s at the top of my picks for the beach this summer.” — Elin Hilderbrand
“There are few more skilled practitioners of the craft of summer fiction than Beatriz Williams.” — New York Times Book Review
“[A] satisfying simmer of a read.” — USA Today on The Summer Wives
Additional Recommendations
Hope you enjoyed the book club discussion questions and reading guide for The Beach at Summerly by Beatriz Williams!
Here are some more of my book club recommendations related to this book:
Welcome to Beach Town by Susan Wiggs
Every town has its secrets…
In idyllic Alara Cove, a California beach town known for its sunny charm and chill surfer vibe, it’s graduation day at the elite Thornton Academy. At Thornton, the students are the worldly and overindulged children who live in gated enclaves with spectacular views.
But the class valedictorian is Nikki Graziola, a surfer’s daughter who is there on scholarship. To the shock of everyone in the audience, Nikki veers off script while giving her commencement address and reveals a secret that breaks open the whole community. As her truth explodes into the light, Alara Cove will face a reckoning.
Nikki Graziola’s accusation shakes the foundation of Alara Cove, pitting her against the wealthy family whose money runs the town. Her new notoriety sends Nikki into exile for years, where she finds fame—but not fortune—overseas as a competition surfer…until a personal tragedy compels her to return to Alara Cove.
As Nikki struggles to rebuild her future, she finds that the people of the town have not forgotten her. But time has changed Alara Cove, and old friendships, rivalries, and an unexpected romance draw her back into the life of the beach town she’s never quite forgotten, and where joy and redemption may be possible after all.
The Seeing Garden by Ginny Kubitz Moyer
Set on a lavish California estate, The Seeing Garden is “a moving story with strong female characters” (Kirkus Reviews) for fans of Edith Wharton and Downton Abbey.
It’s 1910, and Catherine Ogden is aching to live a creative and meaningful life. That’s not easy to do when her aunt and uncle—and all of New York society—consider a good marriage to be the pinnacle of feminine achievement.
But when Catherine visits Oakview, the Northern California estate of handsome bachelor William Brandt, she thinks that it might be possible to satisfy her family’s hopes as well as her own. In that beautiful place, she finds the promise of a new start and the opportunity to use her artistic gifts in designing the garden. But as Catherine is drawn into William’s hidden life, as well as the secrets of his estate staff, she discovers that Oakview holds both more opportunity and more risk than she ever imagined. It will take all her courage—and the lessons of some shocking revelations from the past—to choose the path that leads to real freedom.
Full of rich period detail and complex characters, and set against an unforgettable backdrop, The Seeing Garden explores what it takes for a woman to discern the path to her most authentic life.
My Magnolia Summer by Victoria Benton Frank
Escape to the South Carolina Lowcountry, where family bonds and hidden secrets run deep. In this gripping tale of self-discovery, Victoria Benton Frank introduces us to Maggie, struggling to find her place in the world when she receives a phone call bringing her back to her hometown of Sullivan’s Island.
In New York City winter never seems to loosen its hold and for South Carolina transplant Maggie (born Magnolia after the fairest summer flower) the balmy beach weather of April back home on Sullivan’s Island feels like a distant memory. Until a phone call from her sister, Violet, changes everything.
Gran, the treasured matriarch, has fallen into a coma after a car accident caused by Maggie’s troubled mother, Lily. But once Maggie returns, she finds that her hometown of Sullivan’s Island holds even more secrets. The Magic Lantern, the restaurant owned and run by generations of women in her family, is now rudderless, and her sister seems headed for a savage breakup.
Once she is between the marsh grasses and dunes of South Carolina, she feels herself changing like the Atlantic tides, rediscovering the roots she left behind, and a new and different version of herself—one who can see how a minor crash into the back of a very handsome farmer’s truck may become fortunate. Or perhaps it’s even… fate?
When the three generations of South Carolina women join forces—the family pillar Gran, troubled Lily, impulsive Violet, and redoubtable Maggie—anything is possible.
With stunning descriptions of the magic of the Lowcountry, this novel will transport you to a world of treasured family traditions and unexpected twists of fate.
Happy reading! ❤️